As the eight generations of the Amoraic period progressed, memrot accumulated at an increasing rate. In the many academies in Israel and Babylonia, hundreds of Amoraim studied Tannaitic sources and made their own comments and statements. Students memorized more and more material, attached one memra to the next, and series of memrot began to form. These series are called “sugyot” (singular “sugya”). Since sugyot formed by organic accumulation from one generation to the other, they are almost always in generational sequence, except for very specific types of sugyot described below.

For purpose of categorization and discussion, and to help in learning of the sugya more quickly and easily, sugyot can be divided into various types. The simplest, most direct and most contextual type of sugya are “natural sugyot” consisting of amoraic dialogues. In these sugyot, made of actual amoraic conversation about a given topic, the various opinions are expressed one to the other directly, usually marked with an opening phrase such as “àîø ìéä” or “áòé îéðéä”.

Most sugyot are not “natural” but “edited.” In edited sugyot, individual statements of Amoraim from different times and places are placed one after the other in an clear context or sequence. In these edited sugyot, we distinguish between those from a single academy, multiple-academy sugyot, and sugyot containing amoraic traditions from both Israel and Babylonia.

In single academy sugyot, it can be generally assumed that the memrot were passed in their original form from generation to generation with clear understanding. However, multiple-academy sugyot require more careful examination of their development and editing: how were the units of the sugyah transmitted, and were additional interpretations added to them as they were edited?

Since various academies functioned in different generations, there are clear patterns to multiple-academy accumulation. Generally, sugyot move from Sura in the early amoraic generations to Pumbedita in second to fourth generations. From Pumbedita, sugyot generally proceed to either Mechoza or Mata Mechasia. Alternatively, Sura sugyot may proceed directly to Mechoza or Mata Mechasia if the middle Pumbeditan scholars did not comment, or if they did not see, the sugya.

The last type of amoraic sugya combines traditions from Israel and Babylonia. These sugyot are the most complicated of all, since the contexts of the two locales are so different, and the traditions often require interpretation of culture, language, concepts and customs to be understood. Babylonian amoraic sugyot will either be based on sugyot from Israel, in which case the segment from Israel will appear first in the sugya, or independent from the sugya from Israel, in which case the segment from Israel will be brought after the Babylonian segment. In these “combined” sugyot, generational order will obviously be less consistent than in single or multiple-academy Babylonian amoraic sugyot.

How should amoraic sugyot be learned? Pre-scanning of these sugyot before study of content will identify the type of sugya being studied, and the academy “building blocks” of the sugya. These conclusions will suggest division of the sugya study into stages according to the various academies.

Back to the reading section